You are currently viewing Elta MD Vs Supergoop 2024 – the Comprehensive Guide

Elta MD Vs Supergoop 2024 – the Comprehensive Guide

Elta MD Vs Supergoop 2024 – As you consider sunscreen options for your skin, you’re likely torn between Elta MD and Supergoop, two popular brands with distinct approaches. You might be wondering which one is right for you, given their differing focuses on protection versus moisturizing benefits.

Elta MD’s dermatologist-recommended formulas have been trusted for decades, while Supergoop’s luxury products boast impressive skin enhancers. But which one offers the best value for your skin type and concerns? As you weigh the pros and cons, you’re about to discover which brand comes out on top – and why.

A Quick Overview

  • Elta MD prioritizes protection with antioxidants like vitamin E and ferulic acid, while Supergoop focuses on moisturizing benefits with hyaluronic acid and glycerin.
  • Elta MD offers a range of SPF levels (30 to 50+) and is ideal for acne-prone, oily, and combination skin, whereas Supergoop suits normal to dry skin with gentle ingredients.
  • Both brands provide moisturizing and hydrating properties, but Elta MD’s formulas focus on long-lasting hydration, while Supergoop’s are more lightweight and humectant-rich.
  • Elta MD consistently meets product expectations, with high ratings for gentle, non-irritating formulas and broad-spectrum protection, whereas Supergoop faces some user complaints about performance.
  • Ultimately, the best sunscreen choice between Elta MD and Supergoop depends on individual skin type, concerns, and preferences, considering factors like eco-friendliness, price point, and product performance.

Brand History and Background

Elta MD Vs Supergoop 2024 - the Comprehensive Guide

Discover how Elta MD and Supergoop, two prominent players in the sunscreen industry, have carved out their niches in the market, with Elta MD tracing its roots back to 1965 as a dermatologist-recommended brand and Supergoop emerging in 2007 as a pioneer in the beauty and skincare space.

Elta MD’s founding story revolves around providing effective, dermatologist-tested sunscreens that cater to various skin types and concerns. Their company mission is to educate consumers about sun protection and skin health while offering a range of products that meet these needs.

On the other hand, Supergoop’s founding story is built around making sunscreen a part of daily beauty routines, with a mission to make sunscreen a must-have for healthy, glowing skin.

Key Ingredients Comparison

Elta MD Vs Supergoop 2024 - the Comprehensive Guide

When it comes to sun protection, the quality and efficacy of a sunscreen largely depend on its active ingredients, and you’ll find that both Elta MD and Supergoop formulate their products with distinct combinations of chemicals and natural components that set them apart.

Elta MD’s products feature active antioxidants like vitamin E and ferulic acid, which combat free radicals and reduce oxidative stress.

Supergoop, on the other hand, incorporates skin enhancers like hyaluronic acid and glycerin to hydrate and plump the skin.

These differing approaches impact how each brand’s sunscreens interact with your skin, with Elta MD focusing on protection and Supergoop emphasizing moisturizing benefits.

SPF Levels and Protection

Elta MD Vs Supergoop 2024 - the Comprehensive Guide

When it comes to choosing between Elta MD and Supergoop, you’re likely wondering which brand offers superior protection against the sun’s harmful rays.

You’ll want to ponder the SPF levels and broad spectrum coverage of each product, as these factors directly impact the strength of UVA and UVB defense.

Broad Spectrum Coverage

You’ll want to examine the broad spectrum coverage of Elta MD and Supergoop, as both brands offer varying levels of protection against UVA and UVB rays, measured by their SPF levels.

When it comes to debunking sunscreen myths, understanding the differences in SPF levels is vital. Elta MD offers a range of SPF levels, from 30 to 50+, while Supergoop’s products range from SPF 30 to SPF 70.

Elta MD’s UV Clear Broad-Spectrum SPF 46 provides high protection for sensitive skin.

Supergoop’s Everyday Sunscreen with SPF 50 offers a lightweight, non-greasy formula.

Both brands offer water-resistant options for active users.

Elta MD’s products are often fragrance-free, making them suitable for sensitive skin.

Supergoop’s products are known for their antioxidant-rich formulas, providing additional skin benefits.

UVA/UVB Defense Strength

Both Elta MD and Supergoop offer varying degrees of UVA/UVB defense strength, with SPF levels ranging from 30 to 70.

However, it’s vital to comprehend the nuances of their protection levels to make an informed decision. You might think higher SPF means better protection, but that’s a common sunscreen myth. In reality, SPF only measures UVB protection, while UVA protection is equally important.

The UV index importance can’t be overstated, as it determines the intensity of UV radiation.

Elta MD’s offerings provide broad-spectrum protection, while Supergoop’s products have varying levels of UVA and UVB defense.

When choosing between the two, consider your skin type, lifestyle, and the activities you’ll be doing while wearing the sunscreen. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each brand, you can make an informed decision that suits your needs.

Skin Type Suitability

Both Elta MD and Supergoop cater to various skin types, but their products differ substantially in terms of formulation and ingredients, making one more suitable for your skin than the other.

As you explore these brands, bearing in mind your skin type and needs is crucial. You may want to conduct sensitivity testing to determine how your skin reacts to specific ingredients. Additionally, skin profiling can help you identify your skin concerns and find the best products for you.

Key differences to ponder:

  • Elta MD is ideal for acne-prone skin, thanks to its non-comedogenic and fragrance-free formulas.
  • Supergoop is better suited for sensitive skin, with its gentle and soothing ingredients.
  • Elta MD offers a broader range of products for different skin types, including oily and combination skin.
  • Supergoop focuses on providing products for normal to dry skin.
  • Both brands offer products that cater to skin concerns like hyperpigmentation and aging.

Moisturizing and Hydrating Properties

When evaluating the moisturizing and hydrating properties of Elta MD and Supergoop, you’ll want to examine the hydration levels of each product to see which one provides longer-lasting moisture.

You’ll also need to analyze the moisturizing ingredients in each formula to determine which one is more effective at locking in hydration.

Hydration Levels Compared

Elta MD and Supergoop sunscreen products differ substantially in their moisturizing and hydrating properties, which can greatly impact your skin’s overall hydration levels.

Elta MD’s formulas tend to focus on moisture retention, providing long-lasting hydration to dry skin. On the other hand, Supergoop’s products often incorporate humectant benefits, drawing in moisture from the environment to plump up your skin.

Some key differences to ponder:

Elta MD’s moisturizing properties are more intense, making them ideal for dry or sensitive skin.

Supergoop’s hydrating properties are more lightweight, suitable for oily or combination skin.

Elta MD’s formulas often contain hyaluronic acid, a powerful humectant that locks in moisture.

Supergoop’s products may contain glycerin, which helps attract moisture from the air.

Moisturizing Ingredient Analysis

Four key moisturizing ingredients – hyaluronic acid, glycerin, ceramides, and niacinamide – distinguish Elta MD and Supergoop sunscreen products, each playing a distinct role in their moisturizing and hydrating properties.

You’ll notice that these ingredients work in harmony, creating a moisturizer synergy that locks in hydration and supports the skin’s natural barrier function.

Hyaluronic acid, a powerful humectant, attracts and retains moisture, leaving your skin feeling soft and supple.

Glycerin, another humectant, complements hyaluronic acid, drawing in moisture and plumping fine lines and wrinkles.

Ceramides and niacinamide work together to strengthen the skin’s natural barrier, reducing moisture loss and irritation.

Water Resistance and Durability

Both Elta MD and Supergoop claim to offer water-resistant sunscreens, but the duration of their water resistance and overall durability vary substantially between the two brands. When you’re looking for a sunscreen that can keep up with your active lifestyle, you need to know which one can withstand the test of time and water.

The key differences are Elta MD’s sunscreens being tested in ocean water for 80 minutes, ensuring they stay effective even after swimming or surfing.

Supergoop’s products, on the other hand, are put through rigorous sweat challenges to mimic intense workouts or outdoor activities.

Elta MD’s water-resistance lasts longer, with some products retaining SPF protection for up to 2 hours.

Supergoop’s durability is more focused on its non-greasy texture and comfortable wear.

Both brands have their strengths, but you must weigh your specific needs when selecting the best sunscreen for you.

User Reviews and Ratings

When researching Elta MD and Supergoop, you’re likely interested in what actual users think about these products.

You’ll want to examine the ratings they’ve given for performance, as well as opinions from trustworthy sources.

What Users Are Saying

You can gauge the effectiveness of Elta MD and Supergoop products by delving into the wealth of user reviews and ratings that offer valuable insights into their real-world performance.

These user testimonials and customer feedback provide a unique perspective on the products’ strengths and weaknesses.

Many users praise Elta MD’s gentle, non-irritating formulas and high SPF options.

Some users find Supergoop’s products to be too greasy or oily, while others love their lightweight feel.

Several reviewers rave about Elta MD’s City Broad-Spectrum SPF 40, citing its excellent sun protection and non-whitening finish.

A few users have reported skin reactions to certain Supergoop products, while others have seen no issues.

Product Performance Ratings

By analyzing user reviews and ratings, it’s clear that Elta MD and Supergoop products have distinct strengths and weaknesses when it comes to product performance.

You’ll notice that Elta MD products tend to excel in delivering on their product expectations, with users praising their ability to provide broad-spectrum protection and soothe sensitive skin.

On the other hand, Supergoop products often fall short in respect to real-world results, with some users reporting inconsistent performance and limited wear time.

However, Supergoop’s products are often praised for their ease of use and gentle, non-irritating formulas.

When choosing between these brands, consider what matters most to you: meeting product expectations or achieving real-world results.

Trustworthy Source Opinions

As you research the best sunscreen options, you want to hear from trustworthy sources.

According to dermatologist-backed reviews and ratings, Elta MD products consistently receive high praise for their effectiveness in preventing sun damage and reducing the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles.

Elta MD’s UV Sport Broad-Spectrum SPF 50 is a top pick among dermatologists for its water-resistant formula and non-greasy texture.

Influencer partnerships with skincare experts have showcased Elta MD’s products as a staple in their daily routines.

Expert endorsements from the Skin Cancer Foundation and the American Academy of Dermatology further solidify Elta MD’s reputation as a leader in sun protection.

Users rave about Elta MD’s lightweight, non-comedogenic formulas that won’t clog pores or irritate sensitive skin.

With an average 4.5-star rating across online review platforms, it’s clear that Elta MD has earned the trust of its customers.

Product Variety and Options

Both Elta MD and Supergoop offer a diverse range of products that cater to various skin types and concerns, allowing consumers to choose from a broad spectrum of sunscreens, moisturizers, and other skincare essentials.

You’ll find that both brands boast impressive product offerings, with a focus on formulation diversity.

Elta MD’s portfolio includes mineral-based sunscreens, gentle cleansers, and nourishing moisturizers, while Supergoop’s lineup features a range of SPF-infused products, from sheer serums to rich creams.

Whether you’re looking for a lightweight, everyday sunscreen or a rich, hydrating moisturizer, both brands have got you covered.

With such a wide range of options, you’re likely to find a product that perfectly suits your skin type and concerns.

Price Points and Value

You’ll need to weigh the cost when choosing between Elta MD and Supergoop, as their price points differ substantially across their product lines.

While Elta MD is generally more affordable, Supergoop’s luxury feel and high-quality ingredients come at a premium.

To help you make an informed decision, consider the following factors:

Cost effectiveness: Elta MD’s products tend to be more budget-friendly, with prices starting at around $10.

Luxury feel: Supergoop’s premium products offer a luxurious feel and high-end packaging, justifying their higher prices (up to $60).

Product concentration: Elta MD’s products often have higher concentrations of active ingredients, making them a better value for some users.

Brand reputation: Supergoop’s reputation for high-quality, effective products may justify the extra cost for some consumers.

Bundle deals: Look for discounts and bundle deals from both brands to maximize your savings.

Dermatologist and Expert Recommendations

As you navigate the world of sunscreens, you’re likely to come across professional endorsements from dermatologists and skincare experts.

Many dermatologists and skincare experts recommend Elta MD and Supergoop products, but their endorsements often depend on specific skin types and concerns.

For instance, Elta MD’s UV Sport is often praised by dermatologists for its water-resistance and non-comedogenic properties, making it suitable for acne-prone skin.

On the other hand, Supergoop’s Everyday Sunscreen is recommended for its lightweight, non-greasy texture, making it perfect for daily use.

These professional endorsements not only lend industry credibility to these brands but also provide you with valuable insights to make informed decisions about your skincare needs.

Final Verdict and Recommendation

After carefully evaluating the similarities and differences between Elta MD and Supergoop, it’s clear that the best sunscreen for you depends on your individual skin type, concerns, and preferences.

If you have sensitive skin, Elta MD’s gentle, fragrance-free formulas might be the better choice.

If you’re looking for a more affordable option with a wide range of products, Supergoop might be the way to go.

If you prioritize eco-friendliness, Supergoop’s reef-safe and recyclable packaging might win you over.

If you’re willing to invest in a premium product with exceptional performance, Elta MD’s high-end offerings might be worth the splurge.

Ultimately, weigh your personal experience and product loyalty when making your decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Use Elta MD or Supergoop on Sensitive Skin Around the Eyes?

When applying sunscreen around sensitive eyes, you’ll want to avoid eye irritation and skin reactions. Look for fragrance-free, hypoallergenic formulas that are ophthalmologist-tested, like Elta MD or Supergoop, which are designed to minimize risks and guarantee gentle protection.

Do Either Brands Offer Products for Scalp Sun Protection?

You’re looking for scalp sun protection, and both brands deliver! Elta MD’s scalp serums and Supergoop’s hair care products offer SPF-infused solutions to shield your scalp from harmful UV rays, ensuring a protected and healthy scalp.

Are Elta MD and Supergoop Products Cruelty-Free and Vegan-Friendly?

You’ll be glad to know that both brands prioritize ethics! Elta MD and Supergoop proudly display cruelty-free logos, and some products even boast vegan certifications, ensuring you can feel good about what you put on your skin.

Can I Apply Elta MD or Supergoop Sunscreen Over Makeup?

When applying sunscreen over makeup, you’ll want to follow sunscreen rules: use a lightweight, non-greasy formula and a makeup primer to create an even surface, allowing for maximum protection and a flawless finish.

Do Elta MD and Supergoop Products Expire or Have a Shelf Life?

You’ll be relieved to know that most sunscreen products, including Elta MD and Supergoop, have a shelf life of 2-3 years from the manufacturing date, with expiration dates indicated on the packaging, ensuring product longevity and efficacy.


Based on your thorough analysis, it’s clear that Elta MD and Supergoop cater to distinct skin concerns and types.

If you prioritize protection, affordability, and gentle formulas, Elta MD is the better choice.

However, if you’re willing to invest in luxury products with moisturizing benefits, Supergoop might be the way to go.

Ultimately, consider your individual skin needs and budget to make an informed decision between these two reputable sunscreen brands.


Sofia at delivers insightful and concise reviews on a range of supplements, helping readers make informed decisions for their health and wellness.