10 Best Under Eye Concealer That Don’t Crease

Finding the perfect under eye concealer feels like searching for treasure. You want full coverage that hides dark circles and brightens your complexion. Most importantly, you need a formula that stays put without creasing throughout your busy day.

Dark circles under your eyes can make you look tired even after eight hours of sleep. The wrong concealer makes things worse by settling into fine lines and creating that dreaded cakey look. Quality matters when choosing an under eye concealer because this delicate area requires special attention.

Your under eye area deserves products that work as hard as you do. The concealers on this list deliver professional results that last from morning coffee to evening plans. Each product offers unique benefits that address different skin concerns and preferences.

Tarte Shape Tape Full Coverage Concealer

Tarte Shape Tape stands as the gold standard for full coverage concealers. This powerhouse product delivers buildable coverage that completely covers even the darkest circles. The unique doe foot applicator makes precise application effortless every time.

Features:

• Full coverage formula that builds beautifully
• Available in 35 diverse shades
• Waterproof and long wearing formula
• Contains Amazonian clay for oil absorption
• Doe foot applicator for easy application

Pros:

• Exceptional coverage for dark circles and blemishes
• Long lasting wear that doesn’t fade throughout the day
• Wide shade range accommodates all skin tones
• Buildable formula allows customizable coverage
• Photogenic finish perfect for special events

Cons:

• Can feel drying on mature or dry skin
• Requires setting powder to prevent creasing
• Higher price point than drugstore alternatives
• May oxidize slightly on some skin tones

This concealer works best with a light hand and proper setting. Apply thin layers and build coverage gradually for the most natural finish. The formula responds well to warming between your fingers before application.

IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Full Coverage Concealer

IT Cosmetics created this concealer specifically for under eye concerns. The formula contains anti aging peptides and collagen that improve skin texture over time. This product offers impressive coverage while treating the delicate under eye area.

Features:

• Anti aging ingredients including peptides and collagen
• Full coverage waterproof formula
• Available in 48 shades
• Enriched with vitamins and antioxidants
• Dermatologist tested and recommended

Pros:

• Skincare benefits while providing coverage
• Crease resistant formula that stays put all day
• Extensive shade range for perfect matching
• Suitable for sensitive and mature skin types
• Recommended by makeup artists worldwide

Cons:

• Thick consistency requires warming before use
• More expensive than typical drugstore options
• Can look heavy if overapplied
• Takes practice to blend seamlessly

The key to success with this concealer lies in application technique. Use a damp beauty sponge to blend the edges seamlessly. The formula works beautifully under powder or cream foundations.

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer offers the perfect balance of coverage and comfort. This cult favorite provides medium to full coverage with a natural radiant finish. The lightweight formula feels comfortable for all day wear.

Features:

• Creamy lightweight texture
• Buildable medium to full coverage
• Available in 30 shades
• Long wearing crease proof formula
• Contains optical blurring technology

Pros:

• Natural radiant finish that looks like skin
• Easy to blend with fingers or brushes
• Comfortable lightweight feel
• Excellent color selection
• Works well for both under eyes and face

Cons:

• May not provide enough coverage for very dark circles
• Can separate if not properly mixed
• Medium price range
• Requires regular shaking before use

This versatile concealer works for multiple areas of your face. Use it under your eyes, around your nose, and on any blemishes. The formula blends effortlessly with most foundation types.

Maybelline Fit Me Liquid Concealer

Maybelline Fit Me Concealer delivers impressive results at an affordable price point. This oil free formula works perfectly for all skin types without clogging pores. The natural coverage evens out your complexion beautifully.

Features:

• Oil free non comedogenic formula
• Natural coverage that builds easily
• Available in 12 shades
• Fragrance free formulation
• Lightweight comfortable texture

Pros:

• Budget friendly price without compromising quality
• Suitable for sensitive skin types
• Easy to find in most drugstores
• Blends seamlessly with other makeup
• Perfect for everyday natural looks

Cons:

• Limited shade range compared to high end options
• May require multiple layers for full coverage
• Not as long wearing as premium formulas
• Can look flat without proper setting

This concealer excels as a daily driver for natural makeup looks. Layer it gradually to build your desired coverage level. The formula responds well to mixing with moisturizer for even lighter coverage.

L’Oreal True Match Super Blendable Concealer

L’Oreal True Match Concealer features super blendable technology that melts into your skin. The formula provides natural looking coverage that matches perfectly with True Match foundation. This concealer offers excellent value for professional results.

Features:

• Super blendable technology for seamless application
• Coordinates with True Match foundation system
• Available in 16 shades
• Medium coverage buildable formula
• Oil free lightweight texture

Pros:

• Seamless blending with natural finish
• Affordable drugstore pricing
• Matches perfectly with foundation line
• Comfortable all day wear
• Good for beginners learning application

Cons:

• May not cover extremely dark circles completely
• Limited shade range for deeper skin tones
• Requires touch ups during long days
• Packaging can be prone to spills

Use this concealer as part of the complete True Match system for flawless results. The formula works particularly well when applied with a damp beauty sponge for natural blending.

Too Faced Born This Way Super Coverage Concealer

Too Faced Born This Way Concealer provides super coverage with a comfortable lightweight feel. This multi use formula conceals, contours, and highlights for versatile application. The modern formula delivers photo ready results.

Features:

• Super coverage multi use formula
• Infused with hyaluronic acid for hydration
• Available in 40 shades
• Photo ready finish
• Undetectable lightweight texture

Pros:

• Versatile multi use application
• Hydrating formula perfect for dry skin
• Excellent shade range for all skin tones
• Photo ready finish for special occasions
• Comfortable long wearing formula

Cons:

• Higher price point than drugstore options
• Can emphasize texture if not properly prepped
• Requires proper setting for longevity
• May be too heavy for minimal makeup days

This concealer excels for special events and photography. The hydrating formula makes it perfect for mature or dry skin types. Use it strategically for highlighting and contouring effects.

ELF 16HR Camo Concealer

ELF 16HR Camo Concealer delivers professional quality results at an incredible price point. This full coverage formula provides long wearing performance that rivals high end competitors. The buildable coverage adapts to your needs perfectly.

Features:

• 16 hour long wearing formula
• Full coverage buildable texture
• Available in 25 shades
• Cruelty free and vegan formula
• Budget friendly professional quality

Pros:

• Unbeatable price for the quality
• Full coverage that actually lasts 16 hours
• Extensive shade range for all skin tones
• Cruelty free brand commitment
• Perfect for heavy makeup looks

Cons:

• Can feel heavy if overapplied
• May require warming before application
• Limited availability in some areas
• Packaging feels less luxurious

This concealer proves that quality doesn’t require a high price tag. The formula competes directly with premium brands while remaining accessible to all budgets. Perfect for makeup enthusiasts and professionals alike.

Urban Decay All Nighter Concealer

Urban Decay All Nighter Concealer lives up to its name with 24 hour staying power. This waterproof formula resists humidity, sweat, and tears without budging. The medium to full coverage provides flawless results for any occasion.

Features:

• 24 hour waterproof formula
• Medium to full buildable coverage
• Available in 40 shades
• Humidity and sweat resistant
• Temperature proof performance

Pros:

• Exceptional longevity through any conditions
• Waterproof formula perfect for events
• Wide shade range with undertone options
• Suitable for active lifestyles
• Professional makeup artist favorite

Cons:

• Premium pricing reflects quality
• Can be difficult to remove completely
• May feel slightly heavy on application
• Requires makeup remover for cleanup

This concealer handles everything life throws at you. The waterproof formula makes it ideal for weddings, workouts, and emotional moments. Invest in quality makeup remover for easy cleanup.

Glossier Stretch Balm Concealer

Glossier Stretch Balm Concealer offers natural skin like coverage with a dewy finish. This lightweight formula provides medium coverage while maintaining a fresh faced appearance. The comfortable texture feels like skincare.

Features:

• Skin like natural finish
• Medium buildable coverage
• Available in 32 shades
• Lightweight comfortable texture
• Dewy healthy appearance

Pros:

• Natural skin like finish
• Comfortable lightweight feel
• Buildable coverage for customization
• Perfect for no makeup makeup looks
• Suitable for daily wear

Cons:

• May not provide enough coverage for severe dark circles
• Higher price for the coverage level
• Dewy finish may not suit all preferences
• Requires setting in oily areas

This concealer excels for natural everyday looks. The skin like finish makes it perfect for those who prefer minimal makeup. Build coverage gradually for the most natural results.

MAC Studio Fix 24 Hour Smooth Wear Concealer

MAC Studio Fix Concealer provides professional performance with 24 hour staying power. This full coverage formula smooths imperfections while maintaining a natural finish. The extensive shade range ensures perfect matching for everyone.

Features:

• 24 hour smooth wear formula
• Full coverage professional quality
• Available in 40 shades
• Smooth natural finish
• Makeup artist quality results

Pros:

• Professional quality trusted by artists
• 24 hour staying power
• Extensive shade matching system
• Smooth natural finish
• Suitable for all skin types

Cons:

• Premium pricing reflects professional quality
• May require practice for optimal application
• Can look heavy without proper blending
• Needs setting for longest wear

This concealer delivers professional results every time. The extensive shade range ensures perfect matching regardless of your skin tone. Perfect for those who demand the highest quality.

Rare Beauty Liquid Touch Brightening Concealer

Rare Beauty Liquid Touch Concealer brightens while providing medium to full coverage. This innovative formula contains light reflecting particles that create a radiant finish. The comfortable texture feels weightless on skin.

Features:

• Light reflecting brightening technology
• Medium to full buildable coverage
• Available in 30 shades
• Weightless comfortable texture
• Mental health advocacy brand

Pros:

• Brightening effect for tired looking eyes
• Weightless comfortable wear
• Good shade range with inclusive options
• Supports mental health initiatives
• Modern innovative formula

Cons:

• Newer brand with limited track record
• May be too dewy for oily skin types
• Premium pricing for newer brand
• Limited availability in some areas

This concealer represents the future of inclusive beauty. The brightening technology works beautifully for tired eyes. Support a brand that advocates for mental health awareness.

Tips for Crease Free Application

Proper application technique prevents creasing better than any formula alone. Start with clean moisturized skin for the smoothest base. Allow your moisturizer to absorb completely before applying concealer.

Set your concealer properly using translucent powder or setting spray. This step locks your coverage in place for hours. Apply powder with a fluffy brush using pressing motions rather than wiping.

Choose the right shade by testing on your inner wrist in natural light. Your concealer should match your skin tone exactly or be one shade lighter. Avoid going too light as this creates an unnatural reverse panda effect.

Build coverage gradually rather than applying one thick layer. Multiple thin layers create more natural looking coverage that lasts longer. Allow each layer to set before adding the next application.

Use the right tools for your preferred application method. Beauty sponges work well for seamless blending while brushes offer more precise application. Clean your tools regularly to maintain optimal performance.

How to Choose Your Perfect Shade

Understanding undertones helps you select the most flattering concealer shade. Cool undertones work best with pink or red based concealers. Warm undertones pair beautifully with yellow or golden based formulas.

Test shades in natural light whenever possible for accurate color matching. Store lighting can be misleading and cause poor shade choices. Take samples outside or near a window for true color assessment.

Consider your coverage needs when selecting formula types. Full coverage works best for severe dark circles while light coverage suits minor discoloration. Medium coverage offers the most versatility for daily wear.

Factor in your foundation shade to ensure seamless blending between products. Your concealer should coordinate with your foundation for natural looking results. Some prefer matching exactly while others go one shade lighter.

Setting Your Concealer for Longevity

Proper setting technique determines how long your concealer stays crease free. Use a small fluffy brush to apply translucent powder in gentle pressing motions. Avoid wiping or dragging which can disturb your coverage.

Consider setting spray as an alternative to powder for a more natural finish. Hold the bottle at arm’s length and mist lightly over your entire face. Allow the spray to dry completely before touching your face.

Baking technique works well for special occasions requiring extra longevity. Apply generous powder and let it sit for five minutes before brushing away excess. This method locks coverage in place for hours.

Touch up strategically throughout the day rather than reapplying completely. Use a small brush to apply powder only where needed. Avoid overpowdering which can create a cakey appearance.

Frequently Asked Questions

What causes concealer to crease under eyes?
Excess oil, incorrect application, and lack of setting products cause creasing. Always prep skin properly and set your concealer.

How do I prevent concealer from looking cakey?
Apply thin layers and blend thoroughly. Use the right shade and texture for your skin type.

Should concealer be lighter than foundation?
Your concealer can match your foundation exactly or be one shade lighter for brightening effects.

How long should concealer last throughout the day?
Quality concealers should last 8 to 12 hours with proper application and setting techniques.

Can I use face concealer under my eyes?
Yes, but eye specific formulas typically provide better results for the delicate under eye area.

What tools work best for concealer application?
Beauty sponges provide seamless blending while brushes offer precise application. Choose based on your preference and skill level.

The perfect under eye concealer transforms your entire makeup routine. These ten options provide excellent coverage without creasing for confident all day wear. Choose based on your coverage needs, skin type, and budget preferences. Remember that proper application and setting techniques matter just as much as the product you choose.

Last update on 2025-06-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!